Julia just reminded me that <event> still is not allowed as a child or grandchild of <org>. Off the top of my head, I don't see why <listEvent> is not a member of model.orgPart. Not quite so obvious how to make <event> an eligible direct child of <org>, but it seems like a reasonable request. I plan to submit a bug report shortly, with hopes that we can tackle this and solve it for next release. (Although I have my suspicions that this will bring up other thorny issues.)
This seems completely uncontroversial to me. If <listEvent> can be a child of <person>, it should also be available as a child of <org>. If events happen to people they must happen to organizations too. The mechanics of it are not quite the same; <person> gets <listOrg> through model.personEventLike: http://www.tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/ref-model.persEventLike.... which includes <birth>, <death> and <event> as well as <listEvent>. The little invisible horned thing standing on my shoulder is whispering to me that organizations are also born, and also die, and we use the same vocabulary to describe those events as we do for people. But probably it would be better to use <event type="incorporation">, <event type="foundation"> and so on, to be more precise about what is intended. Cheers, Martin On 15-04-24 01:42 PM, Syd Bauman wrote:
Julia just reminded me that <event> still is not allowed as a child or grandchild of <org>. Off the top of my head, I don't see why <listEvent> is not a member of model.orgPart. Not quite so obvious how to make <event> an eligible direct child of <org>, but it seems like a reasonable request.
I plan to submit a bug report shortly, with hopes that we can tackle this and solve it for next release.
(Although I have my suspicions that this will bring up other thorny issues.)
For those arriving Wednesday night and looking for very American(a) entertainment, Joe Ely will be playing the Ark -- a legend, as they say, of Texas road-house, for those into that sort of thing. http://www.theark.org/shows-events/2015/may/27/joe-ely This is Joe in what I take to be more or less his current state, https://youtu.be/KHl5pqSJkCk And here he is a long time ago in Dublin, channelling Lubbock's own Buddy Holly, https://youtu.be/fmsZrOLBveY pfs -- Paul Schaffner Digital Library Production Service PFSchaffner@umich.edu | http://www.umich.edu/~pfs/
Proposed solution to bug 751 (remember, this solution is not intended as a global fix to the content of <org>, <person>, and <place>, only as a fix to get <listEvent> and <event> to be children of <org>): * new model.eventLike has only 2 members, <event> and <listEvent> a member of model.personPart and model.orgPart and directly part of the content model of <place> * model.persEventLike removed; ND prose tweaked to match - reference to it from content of <person> changed to model.eventLike * model.placeEventLike removed - reference to it from content of <place> changed to model.eventLike * <birth> and <death> added to model.personPart These changes were made to a new branch, https://svn.code.sf.net/p/tei/code/branches/P5/for-bug-751 and checked in to revision 13220. If we like them, we can merge them in; if not, no harm done.
participants (3)
-
Martin Holmes -
Paul Schaffner -
Syd Bauman