On 21/07/16 15:50, Scholger, Martina (martina.scholger@uni-graz.at) wrote:
I think that <surfaceGrp> goes beyond a Simple document, therefore I would remove it.
Well, my reasoning is that whether or not you're doing transcription you will definitely want some way of distinguishing between single page images and images of a page opening, which is precisely ewhat surfaceGrp is for, imho.
Concerning the <line>: If I understand it correctly, <sourceDoc> is not provided within a Simple document?
Krekt
Is it meant to have a transcription within <facsimile> instead? I don't think that <facsimile> should contain a transcription (see also line 790-793 in tei_simple.odd: "A more powerful approach, discussed in section <ptr target="#simple-facs"/> below, is to use the <gi>facsimile</gi> element to define the organization of the set of images representing the text, and then use the <att>facs</att> attribute to point to individual components of that representation.")
Agreed, that putting transcription inside <zone> seems a bit (ahem) odd, but you still need to ability to identify zones on an image, whether or not you put text inside them, and the content model for <zone> allows text. Are you are saying that it should actually be forbidden if the ancestor of <zone> is a <facsimile> rather than a <sourceDoc>?
Therefore I wouldn't restore <line>.
Understood.
-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht----- Von: tei-council-bounces@lists.tei-c.org [mailto:tei-council-bounces@lists.tei-c.org] Im Auftrag von Lou Burnard Gesendet: Donnerstag, 21. Juli 2016 13:42 An: tei-council@lists.tei-c.org; Martin Mueller Betreff: [tei-council] Simple : facsimile
The schema currently makes available within <facsimile> : surface, surfaceGrp, and zone, but not line.
Is that balance about right? Should I restore <line> (which is sugar for <zone type="line">) ? Should I remove <surfaceGrp>?
The purpose is to support a Simple document which contains just images and the lightest of transcriptions, such as you might get from a crowd sourcing transcription experiment for example, not to do full blown genetic transcriptions, obvs.
-- tei-council mailing list tei-council@lists.tei-c.org http://lists.lists.tei-c.org/mailman/listinfo/tei-council
PLEASE NOTE: postings to this list are publicly archived